City Creamery in West Yellowstone

Omg really good ice cream

I used to like it better a few years back. It seems to not be as great anymore, but still decent.

Great ice cream, good flavors, nice workers.

Home made ice cream...great 👍

Great icecream. Good service for amid tourist stream. Bit pricey, but expected.

Refused to serve us because they were “closing soon” even though we arrived 15 minutes before closing time. I would give them a rating of 0 if it were possible to do so.

Fantastic service and incredibly tasty ice cream!! Great little hole in the wall ice cream shop. Lots of different flavors, cones, and shakes to choose from!

Amazing ice cream with excellent service. Highly recommend Wedded Bliss with extra home made hot chocolate fudge. After a full day in Yellowstone we returned around 10:30pm and they were one of the few places open. Very friendly staff that gave us an awesome experience even going so far as showing us how the ice cream is made while they were winding down for the night.

This place is amazing if you are looking for REAL homemade FRESH ice cream! They even make it at the shop! Make sure to try the homemade hot fudge! sooooo yummy

Good ice cream. Can get a little uncoordinated when it's busy. 1 scoop $4

Supa homemade ice cream

Homemade ice cream. When they say home made they mean it and you can see how it's made on site. The ice cream is good. The chocolate and orange ice cream was great and the hukebery lavender was fantastic. The only thing is they do not have sorbes so if you are into that tough luck.

Try "Wedded Bliss" there, you won't be disappointed

This place is the real deal. Retired Army cook that makes his Ice-Cream from scratch and employs foreign exchange students who come on a work visa for the summer.

Good ice cream

Huckleberry with honey and lavender + Green tea with honey on a waffle cone = heaven

Great ice cream and is homemade! Delicious!

Good service. Good variety of flavors. Good texture to the ice cream. The flavor of the ice cream was just okay. I expected a little more excitement for my taste buds.

Sunday is really good. We got cheated on the homemade fudge, we barely got any. Make sure they load that up, it makes the sundae.

I loved their ice cream! And the fact they made it right there was pretty cool! The ice cream was easily 5 stars and really good! I got the wedded bliss! It was really good! They had homemade fudge layered in as well as pecans which was really good. The one thing about this place that made me drop it a star was the cones. They are homemade which is cool, but they crumble and become a mess. They give them to you in an extra cup because of that. I’d rather they just give me a store bought cone that works.

My experience here was bland. The flavors were a little boring and didn't taste that special. Everything was really overpriced (I know it's a tourist town). Honestly though, Dairy Queen has more variety and options, and better tasting ice cream. Probably cheaper too.

Worst ice cream I've ever had

Loved our ice cream! Get the Cowboy Coffee ice cream, you will not be sorry! Delish!

Just stop and grab something you’ll thank me!

So good!!! Would recommend! Mint chip, Double chocolate Orange, and Cookies & cream are all really good!!!

Love it! Great Ice Cream!

Nice little food cart with several flavors of homemade ice cream. Outdoor seating only, and its pretty limited so you might just want to plan to take your ice cream to go. :)

Really great. Such nice people behind the stand and they gave me a big handful of fresh brownies before I ordered. Their homemade waffle cones are truly incredible.

Good ice cream! Reminded me of the ice cream we used to make on the back porch.

Skip this place! We stopped by for ice cream after a day at Yellowstone. My kids said their mint chip ice cream was full of ice chunks and didn't taste like mint. I got "wedded bliss" which was supposed to have hot fudge and chocolate almonds in it. It was tasteless plain ice cream. It was a faint tan color which was the only indication it wasn't plain vanilla. We spent almost $25 buying ice cream for our family and it was a waste of money. I prefer to support local places but I wish we'd just gone to Haagen Dazs this time 😒

Being a GREAT fan of GREAT ice cream, I've been enjoying for years Cold Stone! Two days ago (6/13/18) while visiting West Yellowstone, MT, we tried City Creamery. We had an orange-chocolate cone and a chocolate chip-mint cone. Undoubtedly the best ice cream ever! If you ever get to W. Yellowstone, ya gotta try it! I'll still go to Cold Stone because it's only 7 or 8 minutes away and I find unfeasible to travel 108 miles for an ice cream cone.......or maybe. ...

We stopped for the puffy waffle cone and weren’t disappointed. It was warm and fresh and complimented the ice cream beautifully. The pistachio ice cream in it was top notch as well.

We went twice while in west Yellowstone. The flavors we tried were chocolate, wedded bliss, and raspberry cheesecake. They were all great with the chocolate and raspberry cheesecake being the top two choices in our group. This is really good ice cream!

Great ice cream.

Delicious fresh waffle cones! Friendly personnel who are willing to give samples. We liked the huckleberry ice cream with lavender and honey.

The best ice cream I had enjoyed in a very long time! Double chocolate orange and Cowboy Coffee! Yeah!!!

I have had the smallest serve of ice cream here in my life... Particularly comparing to the serves to people who were after me, who, incidentally, were white and cute... Not sure if I was not white enough, or not cute enough, to get my money's worth serve of ice-cream... 😑

Amazing! The people are super heist and they have a nice little sitting area picnic tables outside. All the ice cream is homemade there and they have so many unique flavors which is also cool!

Ice cream was great. Menu was very hard to read. Staff was not that helpful.

Very good churned ice cream. The only place I've ever seen candied jalapeno ice cream. Kids loved it!

Must stop for the best ice cream!! I have tried probably every huckleberry ice cream in Yellowstone and this one is the real deal!! Their cowboy coffee, raspberry cheesecake, and bourbon pecan is also delicious! The staff is also very delightful!!

Great ice cream

Three little stoners in a stand, making fresh waffle cones as fast as they can. You can smell the cones from down the street. They know what they're doin. Interesting flavor combos too, double chocolate orange, and a green tea ice cream? Join the crowd and get some ice cream, what else ya got to do in this town?

Great ice cream

There was hair in my cookies and cream ice cream. Other than that my ice cream was great besides the hair.

Excellent ice cream actually made old fashioned style on site

This was a fun stop. They had some unique huckleberry flavors and they do in fact churn the ice cream out back. There are two picnic tables, but it's definitely and outdoor affair.

Fast service with great ice cream.

Excellent small batch homemade ice cream. Traditional flavors like chocolate or cookies and cream but also salted caramel and huckleberry honey lavender. I very much look forward to a return visit this week to have their cowboy coffee or huckleberry.

The best deal for ice cream in town!